'Paranormal Activity 3' Only Survivor in Hollywood Horror Film Bloodbath

This story originally appeared in the Oct. 28 issue of The Hollywood Reporter magazine.our editor recommendsBox Office Report: 'Paranormal Activity' Earns $26.2 Mil Friday for Stunning $50 Mil WeekendBox Office Report: 'Paranormal Activity 3' Collects a Franchise Best $8 Million in Midnight Shows'Paranormal Activity 3': What the Moviegoers Are Saying'Paranormal Activity 3': What the Critics Are Saying'Paranormal Activity 3' Trailer Shows Retro Scares (Video) Only a few years ago, a new horror movie was considered as close to a sure thing as anything Hollywood produced. From 2005 to 2009, studios like Lionsgate, Screen Gems, New Line and Dimension made millions releasing hit after hit, grossing north of $50 million at the domestic box office on low-budget slasher pics and remakes of such genre classics as Friday the 13th and The Amityville Horror. PHOTOS: Iconic Horror Movies But this summer and fall, title after title has disappointed, capped by a weak $8.5 million opening for Universal's early Halloween entry The Thing, a prequel to John Carpenter's 1982 horror sci-fi pic of the same name. The likely culprit: The flight of younger moviegoers from the multiplex. Heading into the Oct. 14-16 weekend, The Thing was tracking to gross $11 million to $13 million, but the audience needed to achieve those numbers never materialized. Nearly 65 percent of those buying tickets to the movie were over the age of 25, whereas it used to be that moviegoers under 25 powered the genre. PHOTOS: 'In Time' Premiere Red Carpet Arrivals Other recent titles that have underperformed include the Guillermo del Toro-produced Don't Be Afraid of the Dark, which has only grossed $23.9 million domestic, Shark Night 3D ($18.7 million), Dream House ($18.4 million) Fright Night ($18. 1 million) and Apollo 18 ($17.5 million). "I don't know what's happening. The young people just aren't there," says Universal president of domestic distribution Nikki Rocco. Chris Aronson, senior vp domestic distribution at 20th Century Fox, was one of the first to notice the decline of younger moviegoers, a trend that began during Christmas 2010 and continues to worsen. "These are the kids who are the stable for this kind of fare," he says. PHOTOS: Scream Awards 2011: Red Carpet and Show Photos The Paranormal Activity franchise and Insidious are the only horror movies to do big business of late. Despite the genre's overall weakness, many are counting on Paranormal Activity 3 to buck the trend when it opens Oct. 21, although last year's Paranormal sequel topped out at $84.8 million domestically compared with the $107.9 million earned by the first film in 2009. Still, the sequel cost just $3 million to produce (the upcoming threequel cost $5 million), a scream compared to most studio franchise pics. TOP-GROSSING HALLOWEEN FRANCHISES IN RECENT YEARS Saw (Lionsgate) 7 Films Combined Budget: $64 million Domestic Total: $415.9 million International Total: $457.4 million Total Worldwide: $873.3 million Paranormal Activity (Paramount) 2 Films Combined Budget: $3 million Domestic Total: $192.7 million International Total: $178.3 million Total Worldwide: $371 million The Grudge (Sony) 2 Films Combined Budget: $30 million Domestic Total: $149.5 million International Total: $108.5 million Total Worldwide: $258 million Source: BoxofficeMojo Related Topics Box Office Paranormal Activity 3